Hearing aids and cochlear [ko-clear] implants are very useful devices for children with hearing loss. But they do not completely restore hearing. Many children with hearing loss find it difficult to listen in noisy places like the playground. This is important because many social interactions create noise or occur in noisy places. While most people think we listen through our ears, it is the brain that does most of the hard work! We thought that music training might be a good way to improve listening skills. Why? Because music is a fun activity that involves not only sounds, but also sights, movement, memory, and more! This means a lot of activity and learning, which is good for the brain. What did we find? After 12 weeks of music training, children with hearing loss were better at listening, particularly in noisy environments.
Did you know that sound is made by objects vibrating? When you hear a person speaking, you are hearing the vibrations of their voice traveling through the air as sound waves. Try resting your hand gently on your throat and say, “bees buzz loudly.” Did you feel your throat vibrate? These vibrations are made in your voice box, or larynx [la-rinks].
Sound made by people or objects pass through the air and into your ears. Ears are made up of three sections. The outer ear collects and funnels sound; the middle ear amplifies sound, which means it makes sound louder; and the inner ear transforms sound into electrical signals, which travel to the brain. Finally, the brain gives meaning to these electrical signals. This is how we understand or perceive sound. This whole process is called the hearing pathway (Figure 1). You might be surprised to learn that your brain, not your ears, is the most important part of hearing! Your brain lets you hear all sorts of sounds like waves crashing at the beach, laughter, and songs. What are your favorite sounds, and what do they mean to you? Is music your favorite sound? Did you know that learning music can help people with hearing loss?
Did You Hear That?
Hearing loss occurs when there is a problem at some point in the hearing pathway. A child with a mild hearing loss might have difficulties with soft sounds like whispering. Someone with a profound hearing loss might only be able to hear very loud sounds, like a jet engine or an emergency siren.
Hearing aids and cochlear implants are commonly used to improve hearing loss (Figure 2). Hearing aids pick up sound with a small microphone. These sounds are amplified and come out of a miniature loudspeaker into the ear. Hearing aids work like headphones and mostly make sounds louder. But cochlear implants work very differently. They pick up sounds and send electrical signals directly to the inner ear. Some adults describe the cochlear implant as sounding tinny, robotic, and electric . Fortunately, the brain has an extraordinary capacity to adapt! So, people find that these devices sound better with time, effort, and experience.
Hearing aids and cochlear implants are very useful devices. But they are not like glasses that make everything clear and readable when you put them on. Many children who use hearing aids or cochlear implants find it difficult to listen in noisy places. This can be a huge problem, especially because we often need to talk in noisy environments. Think about how noisy it gets during a class discussion, chatting with your friends in the playground, at a birthday party, or at a busy restaurant. Imagine how much you would miss if you could not hear well in those situations.
Music to Your Ears, But Mostly For the Brain!
Musical activities use lots of brain power! Imagine you are playing the piano. As you read the sheet music in front of you, your eyes tell your fingers which keys to play. Each key you play creates sound, and your ears and brain provide feedback about whether you have played the correct notes. You might be able to play a song by memory, and you can even make up your own song. You can invite other musicians to form a band and play together. All these aspects of music provide the brain with a complete workout—one that relies on sound, vision, memory, creativity, social skills, and more!
The most common way to explore the benefits of music is to look at the differences between professional musicians and someone with little or no musical training. An important discovery is that professional musicians are better at listening in noisy environments than non-musicians are . This means that they are good at hearing what people are saying at a party and they can ignore all the background noise. How do musicians gain this skill? Some may have been born with good listening skills, which could have made them more likely to enjoy music in the first place . But others may have learned to listen better through years of practice. One study showed that children improved their listening skills after 2 years of music training ! So, like most things, your ability to listen in noisy environments probably has something to do with natural talents and lots of practice . You can learn more about music in the brain in this Frontiers for Young Minds article, and this one [6, 7].
Experiment Time, What Did We Learn?
Scientists are only just beginning to understand how music might help children with hearing loss. To explore this, we studied 14 children (between 6 and 9 years of age) with hearing loss, both before and after they received music training. To keep things fair, we only selected children who were born with a moderate to profound hearing loss and who were using hearing aids and/or cochlear implants.
How did we measure listening skills? We asked each child to listen to twenty different sentences such as: “They broke all the eggs”; “Children like strawberries”; or “The clown had a funny face”. The tricky part was that four other voices were also talking in the background, which made things pretty noisy! Every time a child repeated most of the sentence correctly, the noise would become louder. This made the next sentence more difficult to hear. If the child got most of the sentence wrong, the noise would become softer, making the next sentence easier to hear. After doing this 20 times, we calculated each child’s speech-in-noise score. A good speech-in-noise score means that a person can understand speech even when surrounded by lots of loud noise.
To measure our children’s musical skills, we used a test of timbre [tam-ber]. Timbre is how we describe instruments or voices sounding different, even if they are playing the same song at the same speed and volume. Some people like to think of timbre as describing the texture of sound. For example, if you played “Happy Birthday” on a xylophone, it would have a different timbre than if you played it on a harp, or if you sang it. It is timbre that lets you know which instrument is which. In this test, the children had to identify which instrument was playing a short tune. There were eight possible instruments to choose from: piano, violin, cello, acoustic guitar, trumpet, flute, clarinet, and saxophone.
Before the children started music training, we measured their listening and musical skills. twice-12 weeks apart. This baseline measurement result showed that, after simply living their lives as usual, there was no change to any of their skills. The children did no training, and their listening skills did not improve.
After this baseline test, the children began a 12-week course of music training. They joined other children for music therapy such as drumming, singing, and dancing together (Figure 3). They also played musical apps on smart phones or tablets in their own time. These included “drawing” songs, or matching sounds to instruments. At the end of the 12 weeks of music training, we measured the children’s musical and listening skills again. And this time, we found some improvements!
We discovered that children who had completed the training were better at listening to speech in a noisy environment, which was what we were hoping for! The children were also better at identifying various instruments and perceiving timbre. Timbre gives us an important clue about why the children improved in their abilities to listen in noisy environments.
Imagine you are in class, trying to listen to your teacher on a noisy day. There might be all sorts of unwanted, distracting sounds around you. Other children are speaking, footsteps echo through the hallway, students type on keyboards, and laughter from the playground leaks through the window. All these sounds can add up together to become noise. To focus on your teacher’s voice, your brain needs to identify which sounds you want to listen to and which sounds are noise that you want to ignore. Timbre perception helps you do this. You can learn more about separating sounds in this Frontiers for Young Minds article .
Parents of the children also noticed improvements. One said: “We would like to continue with the music program, as our son has made significant progress in the 12 weeks, and we would love for him to go further again! We have noticed that he has become quicker to identify songs on the radio. Even more astounding is that he has suddenly developed some intonation and tune to his singing along, which was previously non-existent.”
All Together Now!
Hearing aids and cochlear implants are amazing devices that help restore some hearing, but not all of it. A common difficulty for children with hearing loss is listening and interacting in noisy environments. It is important to explore ways to improve this skill, as the world can be a very noisy place! We thought music would be a good activity to investigate, as music generates a lot of brain activity. As you now know, the brain is where the most critical part of hearing occurs. After 12 weeks of music training, the children with hearing loss were better at listening in a noisy environment. We hope this will help children with hearing loss live happier lives in noisy and important places like the classroom and playground!
Hearing Pathway: ↑ How sound travels from the ear to the brain and is given meaning.
Hearing Loss: ↑ A problem at some point in the hearing pathway that usually means hearing difficulties.
Hearing Aid: ↑ An assistive listening device that amplifies sounds.
Cochlear Implant: ↑ An assistive listening device that bypasses the outer and middle ear, and sends electrical signals to the inner ear. Sometimes known as the bionic ear.
Speech-in-Noise Score: ↑ A score of how well a person can listen in noise.
Timbre: ↑ How we describe the different sounds of instruments or voices, even if they are playing the same song, pitch, or melody.
Conflict of Interest
CL is currently employed as a consultant for Cochlear Limited. VL was previously employed by Advanced Bionics. However, Cochlear Limited and Advanced Bionics have had no input into any part of this study or this article.
The remaining authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
This study was supported by the Macquarie University Research Enhancement Fund and the financial support of The HEARing CRC. We are grateful to the efforts of the children and their families. We thank Eudora Low and Nordoff-Robbins Music Therapy Australia for facilitating the music therapy sessions. Finally, a big thank you to Grace Howlader for drawing the figures and bringing life to this article.
Original Source Article
↑ Lo, C. Y., Looi, V., Thompson, W. F., and McMahon, C. M. 2020. Music training for children with sensorineural hearing loss improves speech-in-noise perception. J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res. 63:1990–2015. doi: 10.1044/2020_JSLHR-19-00391
 ↑ Peters, J. P. M., Wendrich, A. W., Van Eijl, R. H. M., Rhebergen, K. S., Versnel, H., and Grolman, W. 2018. The sound of a cochlear implant investigated in patients with single-sided deafness and a cochlear implant. Otol. Neurotol. 39:707–14. doi: 10.1097/MAO.0000000000001821
 ↑ Coffey, E. B. J., Mogilever, N. B., and Zatorre R. J. 2017. Speech-in-noise perception in musicians: a review. Hear. Res. 352:49–69. doi: 10.1016/j.heares.2017.02.006
 ↑ Schellenberg, E. G. 2015. Music training and speech perception: a gene-environment interaction. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 1337:170–7. doi: 10.1111/nyas.12627
 ↑ Slater, J., Skoe, E., Strait, D. L., O’Connell, S., Thompson, E., and Kraus, N. 2015. Music training improves speech-in-noise perception: longitudinal evidence from a community-based music program. Behav. Brain Res. 291:244–252. doi: 10.1016/j.bbr.2015.05.026
 ↑ Hambrick, D. Z., Mcnamara, B. N., and Oswald, F. L. 2020. Is the deliberate practice view defensible? A review of evidence and discussion of issues. Front. Psychol. 11:1134. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01134
 ↑ Aubuchon, A., and Mccreery, R. 2020. When choosing NOT to listen helps you hear and learn. Front. Young Minds. 8:104. doi: 10.3389/frym.2020.00104